Book of Mormon Evidence in Lost North American Civilization

Because there are so many holes and flaws with the idea that the Book of Mormon geography took place in South America or Mesoamerica…

Holes and flaws:

1. There are two Cumorahs: the New York Cumorah is not the Book of Mormon Cumorah.

2. Moroni carries the gold plates, Urim and Thummim etc 2500 miles to New York but never mentions this.

3. Isthmus of Tuhantepec is North-South instead of East-West.

4. The Isthmus is 125 miles wide: not your typically 1.5 day march by a Nephite.

….A relatively new idea has emerged.  Rodney Meldrum and many other LDS church members think that the correct area is actually North America around the great lakes, and he affirms that this is what Joseph Smith taught as well. You can view some of these ideas here (just click on an icon to view the video clips). 

The problem is, that this idea contradicts these findings. The findings say that Native American’s came from Asia alone, not Israel. So Native American’s are not Lamanites.  Even if there were advanced, lost Native American settlements around the great lakes, they have the wrong ancestors.

The argument; however, is that there might be a sliver of possibility that a very limited amount of Native Americans actually came from Israel like the Book of Mormon purports. FAIR (Mormon apologists) are skeptical of the North American location based on sketchy DNA evidence, but say that because scientific studies are not 100% iron-clad fact this gives room for the possibility. This sort of summarizes the theory.

During the 1800s, a common folklore was that Jews — particularly the Lost Ten Tribes — were the ancestors of Native Americans and the mound builders of North America. The Book of Mormon (first published in 1830) provides an example of this belief, as its narrative describes two waves of immigration to the Americas from Mesopotamia: the Jaredites (ca. 3000 – 2000 BCE) and an Israelite group in 590 BCE (called Nephites, Lamanites and Mulekites). The Book of Mormon depicts these settlers’ building magnificent cities, only to be later destroyed by warfare around 385 CE. Some Mormon scholars have considered The Book of Mormon narrative a description of the mound-building cultures.

The main problem with saying that evidence of a lost civilization in the great lakes area of North American proves the Book of Mormon is that Joseph Smith knew of this popular 1800’s debate over this possibility and was a fan of the protestant Roger Williams who actively preached about the lost Native American civilizations of North America. The Book of Mormon would be a lot more convincing if it was about an ancient civilization that Joseph didn’t already have an opinion, and knowledge about before he produced the book.

What do you think?

Advertisements
This entry was posted in The Book of Mormon, Uncategorized and tagged , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

4 Responses to Book of Mormon Evidence in Lost North American Civilization

  1. Ancient Explorer says:

    The Book of Mormon shares a lot of similarties to other tall tales of that era used to explain away the moundbuilder culture that had by that time vanished. People didn’t believe that the natives could be that sophisticated. We now know different. http://shadowsofhistory.wordpress.com/

  2. krissmith777 says:

    Hi there,

    I have been blogging on Mormonism myself:

    Could you tell me what you think of these that I have written recently?

    1. http://onlinerationalview.wordpress.com/2011/04/08/the-nephites-lamanites-and-american-indians/

    2. http://onlinerationalview.wordpress.com/2011/04/09/nihm-evidence-for-nephis-nahom/

  3. Liesa says:

    I can only tell you what I know about the Cherokees of North Carolina and Georgia. My grandfather was born in 1889. He always told my father and his siblings about some Cherokees that were blue eyed. Also, they wore turbans and had homes similar to buildings found in the Mediterranean countries. Yes, I am part Cherokee. They also had family tartans and stories similar to the Scottish and their oldest known ancestor was called Kenati (Kennady). So, it’s my understanding that even years ago, portions of America, especially the coastal areas, were melting pots. More central or desert areas were less diversified. I have deeper reasons for believing, but I am basing the facts off of what my non LDS family taught me.

  4. Jc Rodberg says:

    Thank you for this blog, it was just what I was looking for. There is so much information here, so I thank you so much for enlightening my mind.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s